|
Today they are more like a Roman audience rooting
for blood as the Gladiators (read the broadcasting
companies) slug it out in front of them to keep
them entertained and interested. And if they dont
like what they are seeing, they merely walk out
of your stadium and go to someone elses.
In this kind of atmosphere, every individual entity
is stretched to the limit. The advertiser who finds
that his previous levels of budgets are just not
adequate enough
the broadcaster who has to
fight for every last viewer as well as every last
advertising rupee
and the agency which has
to adapt to these changing times as well as manage
their shrinking margins! There are obviously repercussions
of this that we have been seeing in the past few
months. Whether its clients changing agencies much
more frequently or agencies shaking out their unprofitable
businesses or broadcasters getting stricter and
savvier to counter agencies and advertisers, fact
is, its all happening out there! In this situation
while there are some solutions that these entities
have to figure out for themselves, some others are
possible through systems and software.
One such software is the TV Optimiser. It can turn
out to be a tool that each of these entities can
put to great use. For instance, following are the
different aspects on which Optimisers can help:-
However, in this country optimisers have been fairly
under-utilized. It is only in recent days that the
scene has been opening up to using these. Some of
the most well known TV optimisers Worldwide are
SuperMidas and X*PERT.
So
what exactly is an Optimiser? Basic definition
The basic optimiser definition can be broken down
into these key elements :
1. An Optimiser is a software algorithm which optimises
the
reach of a TV schedule, based on a given GRP or
budget
2. A media planner has to specify the channels
and the day
parts in which he could place his ads and enter
the number
of GRPs or the budget or both
3. The Optimiser then designs the best schedule
that gives
maximum reach at given cost levels (or minimum cost
at
given reach levels).
4. The Optimisers could optimise the reach at any
given
exposure level (frequency level)
Types
of Optimisers
Different optimisers from a varied mix of agencies,
have logic, look and feel as well as the final outputs,
which might be somewhat different from each other.
Even if we look at the steps involved while using
an optimiser, we get to understand their different
approaches. If Level 0 indicates start of plan making
and 100 signifies completion of plan and schedules
then, there are Spot Optimisers, which need to be
taken from Level 0 to Level 25 by the planner and
then go from 25 to 100 on their own (shown in chart
1). Then there are Daypart Optimisers, which take
the planner from 25 to 75 and then let the planner
navigate from 75 to 100 on his own in a way that
reflects his buying realities.
Its been observed that Daypart Optimisers are better
suited for Indian conditions. While Spot Optimisers
look easier and would appeal more to planners they
actually can throw at you fairly unrealistic schedules
(for instance, spots like 3rd break, 7th spot out
of 10), which in todays scenario are completely
impractical from a buying or scheduling angle. So
a planner working on a spot optimiser could spend
the same time in attuning the spot optimiser schedule
to reality as converting a daypart optimiser scheduler
into a realistic implementation plan.
Optimisers
can help reduce media costs
The planner can specify either the reach target
and ask for the cheapest cost plan, OR specify the
budget/ GRPs and ask for the reach to be maximized.
Both these options can also work at a frequency
level again specified by the planner. But before
we understand how optimisers work, its critical
to understand and accept the following:-
In a complex scenario like ours with multiple channels,
linguistic markets, metros and small towns, fragmentation,
terrestrial and satellite homes, it is virtually
impossible to arrive at a best plan
manually. The sheer volume of spots and the permutations-combinations
possible ensures that manual plan building is an
impossible task. Hence, a plan that is being made
in that fashion will always be sub-optimal. What
that means in simple terms is that plans being made
today will have some spots that are not adding any
reach. Expenditure on such spots is actually wasteful.
This is evident in the manual plan versus optimiser
plan shown in chart 1 below where it takes more
money in the manual plan to reach a 60% reach level.
|